年前在宋庄,偶然听我的学生提起,前不久来传媒大学演出的一个民谣乐队(山谷里的居民/小娟)的鼓手的妻子是87文编的,我一听就惊了,因为我就是87文编的。当我听到学生提到“于宙”的名字时,我就知道,她肯定是许娜,因为他们当年就是老相好,于宙是北大法语系的,曾经到过我宿舍。而许娜,写的一手好诗,同时画画。我的学生有于宙的手机号,我立刻拨了过去,他说他一会儿要上台演出,让许娜回我电话。过了一会儿,她回了电话,聊了一会儿。毕业之后就没联系过,感觉很亲切。还提到于宙做鼓手的事情,她说,他就是跟着瞎玩儿。我对于宙玩音乐的事情有些印象,似乎记得他当年来我宿舍的时候,曾经给我听过一盘磁带,是一个南美(?)的口琴,嘟嘟囔囔的,非常好玩。没想到,他玩成乐队鼓手了。呵呵。我和许娜说好,哪天一定见见面。
今天回家的时候,在车里听罗大佑的《爱的箴言》。回到家,上网一查,突然发现一个令人震惊的消息:于宙在通州看守所莫名其妙地去世了(密码:aaa)。许娜也被监禁了。网络上有关他们的消息很多都被封了。这个视频是在传媒大学演出时的现场。看着很熟悉。于宙很帅,歌唱得很八十年代,很抒情。让我一下子回到了那个年月。
这是什么世界?
2008-04-15
爱的箴言,by 于宙
2008-04-14
关于DVD的二三事
1、有很多次,人们表示想看我的电影;大部分情况下,这句话的意思是,他们只是希望我给他们DVD。
2、有个住在北京的意大利影评人想看我的新电影,希望我能给他快递一张过去。第二天,我收到他的回信,说那张DVD他收到的时候,已经成了碎片了;没办法,我只好亲自给他送过去。
3、有个电视台的记者想报道一下我的新片,希望我能送给他一张DVD,他们好回去看看,然后再采访我。我们约了时间见面,给了他DVD。然后,过年了,他再也没有和我联系。手机也打不通。我想,这算什么事儿呢?很长时间之后,我终于接到他的电话,说是他的手机丢了。采访报道的事情也不了了之。
4、我的同事之中、同学之中有人非常想看我的电影。我是说,他们非常希望我能送他们一张DVD。至今为止,我一张都没送。这好像是在吊胃口。有时候,时间一长,想看这个电影的心理就会转变成另外一种心理。我也非常急切地想,干脆,就这么给出去吧!可是,我上一次刻的盘已经“自杀”了。
……
与此同时,我的两个电影的拷贝就静静地在我的家里,好像产后的妇女,它们的使命只是“产出”DVD来,然后,就没它们什么事儿了。大多数人只是想看DVD,而不会匆匆忙忙去赶有限的几次胶片放映会。
我辛辛苦苦地拍了两部电影,而遗憾的是,我的两个电影至今没有一个好的DVD版本。所以,每当有人朝我要DVD,我总是像祥林嫂一样把原因解释得很详细,最后说,我手头没有很好的DVD版本,如果想看的话,哪天放映胶片的时候请他们去看。
制作一部胶片电影的DVD,要比制作DV电影的DVD艰难得多。而在国内(北京),为我的电影做一套一般水平的DVD,有时比想像的困难得多:
首先,胶转磁。扫底是最高级的(当然不仅是为了制作DVD),其次是拷贝转磁;而要讲究一点话,需要重新洗印一套“低密度”拷贝,用它来转磁。这个成本最少也要一两万;此外,转成什么视频格式,也是需要衡量的(模拟BETA,数字BETA,高清);
其次,DVD图像数据文件(MPEG2)的制作。转磁之后的原素材至少要模拟BETA,然后在非线上压缩成需要的MPEG2格式——这一步骤不能用一般的民用软件。
第三,声音。符合基本的DVD声音标准(AC3),需要用到混音之后的声音文件,重新MIX成DVD制作的格式;
第四,字幕制作;
第五,花絮(如果需要的话);
第六,压制DVD母盘,批量生产(至少1000张厂家才接活儿);
第六,包装。
好了,到这里才能有一个基本像样的DVD。你说,为了给你一张DVD,需要我如此麻烦,同时花这么多钱!
那么,你说,就一般的DVD就可以了。好的,有一种最简单的方法,就是把胶转磁的录像带拿到某个有此设备的机房(最低要有BETA放机吧),接上光盘刻录机,然后一张一张地出。
我手头有的两个电影的DVD,基本就是这种。这种DVD有什么特点呢?
1、画质极差。因为无法控制压缩比,所以,往往一张盘里的容量只有2、3个G;
2、播放DVD时,经常出现“噎”的情况(速度时快时慢),有时还出现慢动作,然后紧接着出现一个快动作;
3、退化。这个最要命。即使你刻完一张DVD之后,一次也不看,大概半年、一年之后,你就再也看不了它了。我的《葵花朵朵》已经如此这般地刻了好几次了。第一次刻的那个版本早就不能用了。
这次,老猪他们的独立电影展在重庆巡回展,本来我想提供一点好的版本的DVD(因为他们官方要求的HDV或DVCAM格式我没办法做),可是没想到,我差点陷入疯狂!
我于是想到:影展也好,小型看片也好,如果条件允许,最好还是就高不就低。因为,越是低档次的放映条件,格式方面越混乱,越容易出错误(例如,DVD就经常出现在某个机器读不出来的毛病);相反,越是高档次的放映条件,越容易稳定(例如,模拟或数字BETA。乃至胶片)。
看了DVD,不等于你已经看了我的电影。
在DVD中,你只是看到了“故事”。而“故事”,不是电影的全部。特别是我的电影的全部。
而对于另外一些所谓的“电影”来说,在电影院里去看的话,你会觉得特别浪费那个大银幕——它们只是个搞笑的故事,放到网络上就足够了。
我决心不再给任何人提供我的影片的DVD版本了。如果想看我的电影,等凑齐了人数,我可以拿着拷贝随便找个放映厅给大家放。就相当于我请客吃饭了。当然,前提是您得赶一定的时间、跑一定的路程前去,而不会像一般看DVD那样随便——话说回来,您赶我的饭局时,大概也可遵守一定的时间吧!
2008-04-09
竹林七贤:中国异议分子的最早历史

公元263年的春天,发生了中国最早的学生请愿活动。起因是当局判处著名的异议分子、古琴演奏家嵇康死刑。和今天中国当局对于异议分子的看法一致,当局认为,以嵇康为首的一小撮在“皇道开明,四海风靡”的和谐社会里,有组织、有预谋、居心叵测地用“异口之议”“乱群惑众”,使来之不易的稳定大局面临破坏的危险。稳定压倒一切,“今不诛康,无以清洁王道”。他被判刑,按照今天的观点来说,是“言论罪”。
嵇康都“议论”了些什么呢?不是“颠覆政府”之类的政治问题,不是为老百姓“维权”之类的法律问题,也不是泄露国家机密、里通外国的间谍问题,更不是什么“匈独”之类的分裂主义问题(人家本来就是“独立国家”,所谓“五胡十六国”是也)。他基本上都是在议论“形而上”的问题(“玄学”)。
他说,人应该学会“养生”,如果“导养得理”,人活上个千八百岁不成问题;怎么才能“导养得理”呢?他说,“守之以一,养之以和。和理日济,同乎大顺”,总的来说,人的欲望不应该太强烈,而应该“知酒色为甘鸩,弃之如遗;识名位为香饵,逝而不顾”。贪恋富贵和权位,是会折寿的。
他说,自然界的音声本来有悦耳的,有难听的,这是很正常的(“五色有好丑,五声有善恶,此物之自然也”)。各种各样的声音,无论好听、难听,放在一起,“杂而咏之,聚而听之”,才能成为和谐的音乐。一个好的音乐家,不应该事先给各种声音定性,说它是“哀”的(不好听的),或者“乐”的(好听的)。所谓“声无哀乐”。如果一味挑好听的声音来做音乐,恐怕不是真正的“和谐”,会很令人腻歪。应该允许“杂音”的存在。
他说,传统的道德、名教都是很可疑的。应该“越名教而任自然”。譬如,母亲去世了,是不是就不可以喝酒吃肉了呢?只要你内心真正地悲痛,并不一定要通过禁酒食这种外在的仪轨来表现你的“悲痛”,而应从内心真正地体会这种失去母亲的痛苦,方能达到真正的“孝”。真正的道德感,不需要“六经”、“仁义”这种“芜秽”、“腐臭”的玩意儿来体现。
他说,真理不在于人多势众。常识也并不总是无可争议的。“以多自证,以同自慰”,往往是一种虚幻的错觉,心理安慰而已。你看不到,并不等于不存在;他和大多数人不同,并不等于他错了。整个社会如果众口一词,那么,还有什么真理、正义可言?因此,他主张“辩名析理”,拒绝专断,以求得“实有实无”的真知。
……
他还说了很多话;但是,和竹林七贤的其他人不同,他的言论很多,牵涉面很广,但很少在行动上真正地实践他的“玄学”。他不是个严格意义上的“行动主义者”(activist)。
他主张“越名教而任自然”,但是在生活中,他却是个不折不扣的名教实践者:他毫不掩饰对于母亲、兄长的感恩之心,也没有做过类似“七贤”中的其他人(如阮籍)那种蔑视名教的“任诞”之举;他看重朋友情谊,甚至他的具体死因,也是为了朋友(吕安)伸张正义所至;他对于子女的教育,完全是他所反对的那种“礼”(鲁迅甚至很刻薄地说:“嵇康是那样高傲的人,而他教子就要他这样庸碌。”)。他的“礼教”如此成功,以至在他死后,他的儿子对朝廷的忠诚连皇帝都为之褒奖。总之,和其他那些怪人相比,他算是个很平和的人了,王戎有云:“与嵇康居二十年,未尝见其喜愠之色。”
他主张“声无哀乐”,但他临死前所演奏的《广陵散》,却被人评价为“杀伐之声”,远非“和谐”。(当然,也有人评价其为“平和清正之音”,大概是只听了前面的部分,而越到后面,则“疾”“躁”之音似死神来临前的催促。)
他主张“养生”,也曾“常修养性服食之事”;但是他自己却在40岁的时候被判死刑。而其他人,似乎都很好地调适了外部世界和内心世界的平衡,纷纷去做了本来他们不屑一顾的各种官儿,并寿终正寝。究其原因,大概当时的世外高人孙登一语中的:“君才则高矣,保身之道不足。”
他主张“辩名析理”,并不畏烦琐,甚至关于“宅有无吉凶”这样的问题也认真探讨。但是,他却想不明白一件事情:人的“夭寿”到底可求否?
……总的来说,嵇康的言论止于言论,而他也热爱言论之游戏;但是,他的言论游戏却并未给他带来真知以及长寿,反而带来了死亡,以及这死亡来临前的迷惘。
后世很多人说,是嵇康的言论本身使他获罪,因为他的很多议论和当时的主流意识形态相反对(例如“越名教而任自然”,就是对当局所崇尚的“孝道”、“名教”的针锋相对的辩驳)。但这种说法并不全面,因为在竹林七贤当中,比嵇康更厉害的言论和行事比比皆是(例如阮籍)。比起他的前辈孔融来,他反对名教的尺度甚至不是最厉害的。孔融甚至从根本上否定了父母亲情的合理性:“父之于子,当有何亲?论其本意,实为情欲发耳。子之于母,亦复奚为?譬如物寄瓶中,出则离矣。”父亲对于儿子,有什么亲情可言?论其生子的本意,不过是发情的结果;母亲对于儿子,又做了什么呢?就像东西存放在瓦罐里,东西出来了,与瓦罐也就没什么关系了。
还有人说,是“嵇叔夜俊伤其道”,他太尖锐、太眼里不揉沙子了,所以他死了。
又有人说,他的死是因为他和即将被推翻的前朝的亲缘关系:他是司马氏集团的政敌曹魏宗室的女婿。
诸如此类的说法,把他的死亡均归咎于他自己。这类说法实际上是不怀好意的:谁让你该死呢?出身底子本就不好,又说了那么多离经叛道的话,还不给本朝服务,你不死,难道能指望活上千年吗?
我却认为,嵇康的死,是一个自由主义者、无政府主义者的非意外死亡。是一个异议分子在独裁政权下的必然命运。因为,所有的独裁政权,其主要的特点就是:首先,对于“异议”本身的压制,而不是这种异议究竟在多大程度上伤害了政权。事实上,没有任何直接的历史证据表明,嵇康的言论在当时真的“乱群惑众”了,真的造成了社会的不安;也没有直接的历史证据表明,嵇康的言论鼓动了太学生们的静坐。太学生们的静坐只是为了留住一位古琴高手(他们担心“广陵散”真的“于今绝矣”,会影响到我朝的文艺事业),而不是留住一位异议分子。其次,所有的独裁政权,均害怕他的人民当中“有组织”、“有预谋”地做某件事情,哪怕这件事情是一种体育锻炼、或是一种类似宗教的活动。而竹林七贤,这已经是一个组织的雏形,必须扼杀在摇篮里——哪怕它只是学者们的学术“清谈”,而非东汉造成党锢之祸的政治“清议”(这是中国历史上第一次对“有组织”的政党性活动的镇压,但绝不是最后一次)。第三,所有的独裁政权,在惩罚异议人士的时候,总是遮遮掩掩,极力寻找其他借口和契机。嵇康的死亡,是莫名其妙地卷入了一桩兄弟争女的丑闻当中;他的前辈孔融也是。一方面,言者无罪是中国历史上所有朝代(包括当今)的表面文章,没有哪个朝代敢于公开对言论治罪,相反,他们鼓励“文死谏”;另一方面,防民之口甚于防川却是实际的策略。而嵇康就是这样一个牺牲品。
果然,嵇康被治罪之后,“以儆效尤”的效果立刻出来了:“竹林七贤”的团伙解散,大家纷纷去做官,少说话、少臧否人物成为最高美德。司马氏集团成功地主宰了政权,晋朝开始了——但也仅仅维持了50年。
2008-04-01
人民、国家、超国家、主权和自由
1、人民:人是单数,民也是单数;不同的是,“人”是一只蚂蚁,而“民”是一群蚂蚁,却假装是一只蚂蚁。“人”的对立面,不是“兽”,而是“人民”。它可以人民的名义将你处死,却从来没有过以人民的名义让你的幸福的可能性。人民是世界上最强大、最无法无天的庞然大物。人民是强权。
2、国家:从历史和理论上说,“国家”的含义是“民族国家”,历史上很少有多个民族自觉结成一个国家,主要是趋势都是单个民族组成单个国家。如果有,那也基本上是强权所致:一个强大的民族强迫另外一个/一些弱小的民族加入他的国家。如果世界上没有这些强权,恐怕每一个民族都会变成一个国家。中国直到1862年才算有了一面可以代表“国家”的旗帜,中间有一条龙的三角黄旗——那只是个临时的替代物而已;而在此之前,中国的地方基本上是自治的。
3、超国家:一些无法结成国家的实体组成了“超国家”,它们或者业已消亡,或者名不副实:大不列颠帝国、独联体、欧盟、联合国……
4、主权:它是世界上最没用处、却又死缠滥打、无法摆脱的东西——作为个人,你的国家所拥有的主权和你有什么关系?你并不能免费使用你国土上的一切,正如你不能免费使用别的国土上的一切;在你贫穷的时候,首先是你的国家抛弃了你;在你的自由被剥夺的时候,你却无法自动剥夺你的国籍;战争发生的时候,“主权”只会让你当炮灰,战争胜利却又没你的份儿;我羡慕电影里的法国人,每一次战争,法国人总是不抵抗就投降了,战火在法国的损失最小,——不,还有另一个国家,捷克,自由主义的福地。
5、自由:就是当战争发生时,能够和你的情人自由地上床,而不考虑他是否汉奸、是否白种人、是否纳粹。性爱无国界。自由也是。
自由和国家的关系:当国家自由了,个人的自由便处境危险了。
自由和人民的关系:人民永远不能自由,只有个人能够自由。
自由和主权的关系:主权消失之日,便是全世界的个人自由之日。至少他不用签证而能去世界上任何地方。
2008-03-28
境外记者西藏采访团遭遇喇嘛们的“干扰”
Tibetan monks disrupt an official news briefing at a temple in Lhasa, accusing the Chinese authorities of lying about recent unrest. Video courtesy of Reuters.Monks Disrupt Tour by Journalists,
Complain About Lack of Freedom
Associated Press
March 27, 2008 12:32 p.m.
LHASA, China -- A group of monks shouting there was no religious freedom disrupted a carefully orchestrated visit for foreign reporters to Tibet's capital Thursday, an embarrassment for China as it tried to show Lhasa was calm following deadly anti-government riots.
A Foreign Ministry spokesman later insisted that Tibetans had full rights and warned Europe not to interfere. Meanwhile, the Dalai Lama, the region's exiled spiritual leader, said he was in touch with "friends" about pursuing a dialogue with China, adding that Chinese authorities "must accept reality."
Officials arranged the trip for the reporters to showcase that Lhasa was at peace after the mid-March violence and a subsequent government crackdown shattered China's plans for a smooth run-up to the Beijing Olympics.
The outburst by a group of 30 monks in red robes came as the journalists, including an Associated Press reporter, were being shown around the Jokhang Temple -- one of Tibet's holiest shrines -- by government handlers in Lhasa.
"Tibet is not free! Tibet is not free!" yelled one young Buddhist monk, who started to cry.
They also said the Dalai Lama had nothing to do with the riots by Tibetans in which buildings were torched and looted and ethnic Han Chinese were attacked. The government has said the March 14 riots were masterminded by "the Dalai clique," Beijing's term for the Dalai Lama and his supporters.
Government handlers shouted for the journalists to leave and tried to pull them away during the protest. "They want us to crush the Dalai Lama and that is not right," one monk said during the 15-minute outburst.
"This had nothing to do with the Dalai Lama," said another. The Chinese government says 22 people died, while Tibetan exiles say the violence plus the harsh crackdown afterward have left nearly 140 people dead.
The rioting and four days of protests that preceded it were the worst anti-Chinese demonstrations in Lhasa in nearly two decades and they sparked protests in Tibetan areas across a vast portion of western China. The Chinese government has maintained its response was measured and comparable to what any responsible government would do when faced with civil unrest.
The outburst by the monks came amid a morning of stage-managed events. Reporters already had been taken to a Tibet medical clinic that had been attacked nearby the Jokhang, and shown a clothing store where five girls had been trapped and burned to death.
The monks, who first spoke Tibetan and then switched to Mandarin so the reporters could understand them, said they knew they would probably be arrested for their actions but were willing to accept that.
They had rushed over to stop the reporters from being taken into an inner sanctum of the temple, saying they were upset that a government administrator was telling the reporters that Tibet had been part of China for centuries.
They said troops who had been guarding the temple since March 14 were removed the night before the visit by the reporters. One monk said they were upset by what he said were some monks planted in the monastery to talk to the journalists, calling them "not true believers but .. Communist Party members."
"They are all officials, they [the government] arranged for them to come in. And we aren't allowed to go out because they say we could destroy things but we never did anything," another monk said.
The protesting monks appeared to go back to their living quarters. There was no way of knowing immediately what happened to them.
China rarely lets foreign reporters into Tibet under normal circumstances, so the media tour was meant to underscore the communist leadership's determination to contain any damage ahead of the Beijing Olympics in August that was supposed to celebrate China as a modern, rising power.
The official Xinhua News Agency reported Thursday on the action by the monks, but did not say what the monks yelled out.
Later, the area around Jokhang was sealed off by People's Armed Police wearing helmets and carrying shields. They refused to say why they were there. The only people allowed to enter the area were those who live in the narrow lanes around the temple.
Most of the shops near the temple were also closed.
Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang said at a news conference Thursday that various ethnic groups in Tibet are "safeguarding the national unity and oppose separatist activities."
Mr. Qin also warned Europe not to interfere with the situation in Tibet ahead of a two-day meeting of foreign ministers from the 27-member European Union. The unrest in Tibet is China's internal affairs, Mr. Qin said. Beijing hopes European countries will not send "erroneous messages" to the Dalai Lama, Mr. Qin said.
"I believe there are criminals, especially violent criminals, in the European countries. .. I hope that Europe will not adopt a double standard in this regard," Qin said.
Meanwhile, the Dalai Lama said he was in touch with "friends" to get a dialogue going with Chinese officials.
"I think this is time the Chinese government and Chinese officials, I think, must accept the reality. I think that's important. Now in any case we are [in the] 21st century, pretending or lies cannot work," he said, speaking in New Delhi.
Reporters in Tibet who tried to break away from the group were subject to being followed on foot and by car. Only furtive conversations with Tibetans were possible.
"Ethnic unity? This war is an ethnic conflict," said one middle-aged Tibetan in a shop selling yak butter in the Old City of Lhasa.
The reporters were taken to places that had been well publicized on state television as places the rioters had attacked. That included the Lhasa No. 2 Middle School near Ramoche, where protesters had hurled burning objects that set fire to one two-story building. Nobody was hurt at the school.
The principal, Deji Zhuoge, said he did not know why the school was attacked. He said 85% of the schools 620 students were Tibetan.
But the reporters were kept away from any potential hotspots, including the Ramoche monastery. Down a lane north of the Jokhang, Ramoche is where the violence started on March 14.
The narrow lanes leading to it were sealed off by riot police in dark blue uniforms.
The government handlers also told the reporters they would not be able to see Drepung and Sera monasteries, where initial protests were launched March 10.
Reporters were shown a detention center that housed some of the rioters and an assistance center for those who lost homes or businesses in the violence.
At the assistance center, a man from who moved to Lhasa from central China to open a store last year said he and his wife were forced to jump from the second floor when a crowd set his small shop on fire during the rioting.
"We never thought this kind of thing would happen and leave us with nothing," Li Kunjian said.
Copyright © 2008 Associated Press
--------------------------------
境外记者西藏采访团遭遇喇嘛们的“干扰”,“哭诉缺少宗教自由”,并说“达赖喇嘛和最近的暴力活动无关”,
另请参看更清晰、更完整的视频报道(CNN)。
该视频报道中,喇嘛们纷纷哭诉说,“我们要自由!”“他们不让我们出去!”“他们相信我们,我们根本没有“打砸抢烧”,并说,在寺庙里祈祷的都是“骗人的,都是干部”……
以下为国务院新闻办组织的境外媒体的相关报道:半岛电视台、南华早报、华尔街日报/美联社
